Euthanasia is not a Charter issue

Euthanasia is not a Charter issue

With significant opposition by a number of their own MP’s the Trudeau government  is justifying their support for  an ill-conceived and dangerous euthanasia bill with the totally false claim assisted dying is a “Charter right.”

When the Supreme Court struck down Canada’s assisted suicide act it was not giving activists the right to read into the Charter a “right to die.” So when Liberal House Leader Dominic Leblanc glibly justified the Liberal decision as a “Charter of Rights” issue he was wrong. This use of the charter is misleading, dishonest and an abuse of Parliament and tramples the rights of those who for conscience and moral considerations oppose the bill.

Long term Liberal MP John McKay said “It’s not core to the government’s mandate; it’s a response to the Supreme Court,” he said. “I don’t see this as a Charter issue.”                  

In striking down the assisted suicide law the Supreme Court in using imprecise and subjective language made an activist decision that sets a dangerous precedent which if unchecked could  lead to the kind of abuses now common in the Netherlands, Belgium and Switzerland.

Canada’s euthanasia lobby is pushing for euthanasia for psychiatric reasons such as depression, for example, where a person incapable of making their own decision could die an assisted death. Assisted suicide is in reality an abandonment of seniors, people with disabilities and other socially devalued people such as those who suffer from depression.    

The Liberals need to prove they respect Parliament and democracy and follow the example of the opposition Conservative and NDP parties and allow for a free vote. It is simply unconscionable and wrong to force people to vote against their conscience. To call such a radical interpretation of the Charter that would allow the extinguishing of lives a slippery slope is no exaggeration.

 

Gerald Hall
Nanoose Bay, B.C.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.